April 6, 2013
-
Find a Man Today, Graduate Tomorrow
Find a Man Today, Graduate Tomorrow
Susan Patton told young women to look for a mate in college. Liberals went crazy. My mom said the same thing.
By EMILY ESFAHANI SMITH
In 2008, when I was a college junior, I went home to New Jersey one weekend to visit my family—and almost immediately regretted it. My mother seemed more interested in my romantic life than my academic life: “Have you found a boyfriend yet?”
I rolled my eyes and said no. With a healthy dose of young-adult arrogance, I explained that I was too busy studying, working on the college review, and helping out at my sorority. No time for men. My mother nodded, acknowledging that there was a lot going on.
Then she said calmly but forcefully: “You’re in college. You’re at Dartmouth. There will never be a better time to meet someone. I’m sure there are many interesting boys around. If you don’t find one before you graduate, you might not find one at all—so start looking.”
Related Video
Best of the Web Today columnist James Taranto on why Princeton alumna Susan Patton was right to suggest that smart women should try to seek out husbands in college. Photos: AP
Fast forward to today. A woman named Susan Patton is being pilloried online and elsewhere for giving young women the same advice that my mother gave to me. Late last week, she wrote a letter to the Daily Princetonian newspaper advising the school’s female students: “You will never again have this concentration of men who are worthy of you. . . . Find a husband on campus before you graduate.”
Feminist attacks on Ms. Patton began immediately—the paper’s website was swamped with complaints, the Twitter crowd was livid, and writers lit into her at Slate, New York magazine and beyond.
To call Ms. Patton anti-feminist is misguided at best. She was the first woman in her family to attend college. In fact, she was in one of the first classes of women to graduate from Princeton after the school went coed in 1969, and she had to fight her parents to go. Her parents, who were Holocaust survivors, thought a woman’s place was in the home. Ms. Patton has spent the years since her 1977 graduation carving out a successful career in corporate America.
Getty Images
My mother, too, has blazed her own trails as a woman. Born in Iran to a middle-class family, she worked so hard in high school that she was one of only a handful of women admitted to the country’s most prestigious engineering university. After the 1979 Islamic Revolution, which drastically changed Iranian life, especially for women, she packed her bags and headed west—first to the United States, then to Canada, where one of her early jobs was flipping burgers.
She eventually started working as a chemical engineer and has, like Ms. Patton, enjoyed a successful career. My mom benefited enormously from the freedom and opportunities that feminism gave her—opportunities she would have been denied in Iran.
So have I. For my entire life, my parents have pushed me to work hard and be independent, to be capable of supporting myself emotionally and financially.
That is precisely why my mother’s advice five years ago stopped me in my tracks. If she, a strong, career-oriented feminist—who, with my dad, sacrificed a great deal for me to go to college—was telling me to pay more attention to my romantic life, then what did she know that I didn’t?
A lot. She knew what few, if any, feminists would tell young women today: There is far more to happiness than career success.
Before Susan Patton wrote the letter that went viral, she had attended a Princeton conference about women and leadership. In one of the conference sessions, Ms. Patton and her best friend since freshman year of college met with undergraduate women ostensibly to talk about their careers. As she explained in the letter, though, the undergrads were less interested in discussing jobs than relationships and other personal matters.
Ms. Patton wrote that one of the young women asked how she and her friend had sustained a friendship for 40 years: “You asked if we were ever jealous of each other. You asked about the value of our friendship, about our husbands and children. Clearly, you don’t want any more career advice. . . . You know that there are other things that you need that nobody is addressing. A lifelong friend is one of them. Finding the right man to marry is another.”
In a boardroom somewhere, Sheryl “Lean In” Sandberg’s heart is sinking.
Career success and relationships are both undoubtedly important to women’s happiness, but many young and ambitious women value their personal lives more than their career aspirations. And that feeling intensifies over time.
In a 2009 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, David Lubinski and his team at Vanderbilt found that in a sample of academically gifted young adults, women became less career-oriented than men over time. As they approached middle age, women also placed more value than men on spending time with family, community and friends. These differences became more pronounced with parenthood.
My mother’s advice—Susan Patton’s advice—may not be right for every woman, but it was right for me. In the fall of my senior year, I started dating a brilliant man and we’re still together. If I were unattached today, I’m not sure what I would do. The post-college dating scene can be rough: Getting to know someone often means shouting across a noisy bar or scrolling through Internet dating profiles. Finding a partner in college is easier.
Mom was right.
Ms. Smith is an associate editor of The New Criterion and editor of the blog Acculturated.
A version of this article appeared April 5, 2013, on page A15 in the U.S. edition of The Wall Street Journal, with the headline: Find a Man Today, Graduate Tomorrow.
Copyright 2012 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved
Comments (1)
I am so delighted that an extremely smart woman would speak truth to younger women who are finding themselves middle aged, still longing for children, straight sexually, and watching their colleagues with whom they graduated with looking at new college grads instead of at them. College is a great place for relationship building, for you do meet people who know the ground you have walked up on, and that it is still alright to have a traditional relationship which does not have to be approved by the ultrafeminist who find man bashing still the optimal way to feel about most men and their behavior.
It is always fascinating to me that if we speak of tradition, education, religion, and younger couples building families, then it becomes the immediate target for women, most who have not experienced a successful relationship with a male to burst in to with their opinions of how pathetic women who treasure these qualities and have dreamt since they were little girls that their passions are to be demeaned. What is the threat ladies? Women can do any thing we want in America, but child birth and sexual relationships using similarity in values and backgrounds just seems to strike a chord that we are going to lose something. Actually, we may gain something, such as healthier newborns. fathers and mothers who parent together allowing for a child to know men and women actually have body parts that were designed to create a new life, and the youth of the parents is apt to allow them more years to enjoy their off spring’s children. Oh my God; could we actually be noticing that over two thousand years of marriage among men and women actually had healthy outcomes and allows for gender differences. How can we possibly believe that something old might actually be something very good, and that there is a place for traditional families.
Of course this brilliant woman is going to have one hell of a backlash, because the goal was no longer Women and equality. No, the goal has become to create a society where marriage among the different sexes is old news, and if we start inching back to regain some of the joyful life found in the old fashioned institution of marriage, then we may have a conflict of moving forward with GLBT marriages, and that is the darned truth, and few will stick their necks out to say so. I believe the GLBT community has little to worry about, for — If all of the polls are correct, then gay marriage will become a reality, even with the Supreme Court as state by state attitudes change, so how about giving Ms. Patton a break, for she knows that many of these women and men will not have the privilege of ever knowing what the original marriage involved, and college is certainly a happy time of life to seek out like minded mates. Can we see a little bigotry arising from another camp? Or is bigotry only applicable to those who found their parents and grandparents were not so screwed up after all?